What Now? | A blog dedicated to anything and everything under the sun.

I smell a David (Cook) vs David (Archuleta) on the season finale of American Idol.

Here are videos of David Cook’s performance on American Idol last May 13 where he showcased his rocker genre (at least for two songs).

Performer’s Choice: Dare You to Move by Switchfoot

Simon Cowell’s Choice: First Time Ever I Saw Your Face by Roberta Flack

Producer’s Choice: I Don’t Want to Miss a Thing by Aerosmith

(I have to agree with Randy Jackson, it was kinda expected that he would sing it this way. Still, I bet he must have melted hearts again all over the world.)

Moving over to the pretty boy David Archuleta’s performance (whose dad, Jeff Archuleta, was banned from American Idol rehearsals according to reports)

Performer’s Choice: With You by Chris Brown
(Something’s off with his performance. It looked awkward… well, at least for me. Agree?)

Paula Abdul’s Choice: And So It Goes by Billy Joel

Producer’s Choice: Longer by Dan Fogelberg

No offense to Syesha Mercado’s fans but she seemed like a wallflower to me. But who knows, she’s the season’s darkhorse and may even end up a winner, right?

Contestant’s Choice: Fever by Peggy Lee

Randy Jackson’s Choice: If I Ain’t Got You by Alicia Keys

Producer’s Choice: Hit Me Up by Gia Farrell

So hmmm… what do you think???